If you live in a positive type of suburb, some of the approaches that students and parents boast approximately entering into the “right” colleges. The casual references to making plans for Cambridge or New Haven. The decals or bumper stickers on cars. The constant questions about “where is your son/daughter making use of/going?” The process builds the form of competitive environment that provides to pupil strain and leaves many feeling inadequate because their university dreams do not include attending the maximum prestigious of institutions.
Then there may be the university map, which at elite high schools is a characteristic of the give up of the college year. A map of the US suggests all of the places students could be off to inside the fall. Students supply permission to have their names connected to the map’s locations, so everyone at elite faculties can analyze what number of are headed for the Ivies and which of them. At The Campanile, the pupil newspaper of Palo Alto High School, the map has been an annual way of life. The image above is from a few years in the past (and we’ve cropped out the lists of pupil names and their university locations). Palo Alto High School, located inside the backyard of Stanford University, and attended by using youngsters of professors and Silicon Valley executives, year after yr sends many students to what are considered the great faculties within the united states of america.
This year, inside the wake of the admissions scandal that has targeted interest on parents who appear extra targeted on status (at any value) than finding a good in shape among scholar and college, editors of The Campanile decided on a new technique. They killed the map.
“The Post-Paly Plans Map has historically been one among The Campanile’s most tremendously predicted pieces. Though its supposed reason changed into to rejoice the postgraduation plans of each senior, the truth is the map contributes to the poisonous, evaluation-driven way of life at Paly,” wrote the newspaper’s 5 co-editors in leader in an editorial pronouncing the decision. (Paly is how they talk to their high faculty.)
“Our network fosters a university-centric mind-set, which erodes one’s experience of price and can cause students with less conventional plans feeling judged, embarrassed or underrepresented. This worldview units the bar for achievement extremely high and punishes all and sundry who falls quick. We agree with the load of improving Paly’s surroundings falls on the students. If we don’t shift how we speak and think about college, the culture will in no way improve. This is the cause we determined not to submit the map this yr.”
The editors surrounded their editorial with bins wherein a few participants of this 12 months’s senior elegance mentioned their university picks — and amongst the ones sharing their memories have been students who turned down more prestigious for much less prestigious colleges.
Gila Winefeld wrote, “At Paly, there’s kind of a norm of going to the ‘excellent,’ maximum selective college you could get into. Sometimes other factors that can be important like proximity to home and cash fall to the wayside, but I realized a variety of the ones elements had been vital to me and my own family … There have been clearly some times wherein humans, even though they didn’t say it straight to my face, implied that in case you’re an amazing student, why aren’t you going to a ‘better’ university, a ‘better’ school. I had a few specific options I turned into searching at and I had some extra prestigious options so loads of people were very taken aback once I informed them that I had determined … One individual even requested me, ‘Oh, do you no longer care in any respect?’”
Several college students wrote of their delight at going to community college and the stigma associated with such a choice.
Bryan Kagiri wrote, “Personally, I suppose community university is a wonderful, fantastic plan. The stigma is that in case you aren’t going to a four-yr human beings appearance down on you. I take a look at it the alternative manner — if you’re going to a -yr that means you’re confident sufficient that you can assist your self out. I don’t recognize why there’s the sort of poor view on network college, due to the fact I suppose it’s a exquisite idea financially and mentally for a senior.”
Along with the student voices turned into that of Arne Lim, an alumnus who is mathematics education manager at the high school. He wrote that the admission scandal is “no longer a by-product, it’s miles an immediate made of believing you have to do some thing you could to get your youngster into this college … We hate those [U.S. News and World Report] rankings right here, we virtually abhor those scores. You will constantly pay attention … college is a fit, it is not a praise.”
Previous essays in The Campanile make clean that — regardless of the sentiments of the editors of the newspaper — others at the faculty appearance down on people who deviate from the Ivy direction.
“On college blouse day closing yr, a day this is supposed to permit students to reveal delight for his or her post-excessive college plans, a student wore a Foothill College blouse with the phrases ‘Sorry, Mom’ written on the back. This message exemplifies the shame that many college students planning on attending network college may experience due to the Paly’s subculture of immoderate competition. Students must not be made to sense this way about their university desire,” said one essay.
It persevered, “The desire to enroll in a network college is regularly seemed as inferior in the broader Paly community due to a lifestyle of excessive opposition. While it is rare for college kids attending network college to be explicitly shamed, the overall attitude when one discloses that they are attending a network college is a great deal much less congratulatory than the mind-set in the direction of students who announce they will attend a greater high-profile college.”
For the editors in leader, the subject matter of college admissions as a corrupting impact — one they addressed in killing the map — is also some thing they have written about previously.
Last month, as news of the scandal unfold, they wrote in some other editorial:
“Throughout our time at Paly, we’ve witnessed — and, admittedly, sometimes contributed to — the ugliest parts of this tradition. Paly fosters a goal-orientated student thoughts-set, and we often allowed this mind-set to dictate our personal self esteem and our view of our friends. As seniors, we’ve emerged from the darkish cloud of the college admissions process and have witnessed firsthand the manner that it erodes one’s feel of fee and region,” wrote the editors, Leyton Ho, Waverly Long, Kaylie Nguyen, Ethan Nissim and Ujwal Srivastava.
They added, “Frankly, no one may be blamed for valuing the glitz and glamour of a prestigious institution or high GPA. But there’s more to being human than success — we think the force for classic measures of validation can force students to miss some of the most valuable instructions and experiences excessive faculty can offer.”